Skip to main content

The Ohio Bucket List

Authentic Mexican paletas, ice cream, mangonadas, and over-the-top frozen treats.

Follow @OhioBucketList

A Bucket List Experience in Columbus

Diamonds Ice Cream is one of those dessert spots that feels fun the second you walk in. Located in Columbus, this family-owned shop is known for authentic artisan Mexican paletas, house-made ice cream, fresh fruit treats, mangonadas, aguas frescas, and classic Mexican snacks.

What makes it stand out is the variety. You can stop in for a scoop of ice cream, grab a colorful paleta, order a loaded mangonada, or go for something savory like elote or esquites. It is the kind of place where everyone can find something, whether you want something fruity, creamy, sweet, spicy, or refreshing.

If you are looking for a dessert stop that feels different from a typical ice cream shop, Diamonds Ice Cream is a must-try in Columbus.

5461 Bethel Sawmill Center Columbus, OH 43235

Know Before You Go

✔️ Known for Mexican paletas and artisan ice cream
✔️ Mangonadas are one of the must-try items
✔️ They offer both milk-based and water-based popsicles
✔️ Savory snacks like elote and esquites are on the menu
✔️ Great for families, dates, and casual dessert runs
✔️ Menu has both sweet and spicy options

More Experiences In Central Ohio

Kung Fu Noodle

The Feast Buffet